Sure. I can imagine how it usually goes. A person is a fan of whatever he have read, and he sees all the adaptations of this story as only tributes to the original one. Then of course he wouldn't be happy about any changes. I don't care about things like that though, don't feel a need to build a shrine to any story and guard its wholeness
Yeah, people make up things like that to make themselves feel better or something. Kinda silly. If you only read manga you miss out on animation, colored art, music, scene composition, voice acting, etc. If you only watch anime you miss on artistic style details, manga-only things like panel layout, generally on unique idiosyncrasies of the mangaka. Both are good in their own ways. Though it is good to cut the manga readers some slack, you won't believe how hard it is to talk about an anime which you haven't seen, but read the manga, and not sounds like a pompous moron : D It usually not intentional :lost2:
It is probably thanks to the story and OPM popularity. Mob is well written and people have been waiting for it, so the unusual animation didn't kill it. I wonder if One will make a new project after Mob webtoon is done, and how long he is planning to keep going with OPM.
I guess. Madoka's visual style mixes postmodern art, abstract art, surrealism, not to mention all the references and whatnot. I feel like it is far from being a normal anime style. It looks normal though, on the first glance. Maybe that is a good way to make experimental animation, I dunno. Maybe the team was just that good. They did a great job matching the visuals to the story too. In Kubikiri they also play this game, but there it is all about heavy stylizing, not nearly as subtle and complex as in Madoka. You'll see what I mean if you watch it. Better find an HD version by the way, it is worth it for sure =)
It is also interesting that the music and character designs in Madoka are completely normal and lite. They could have found some avant garde music for this show, but I think it wouldn't have worked as well as it did with its current OST. I am trying to think of any show where they would use some hardcore soundtrack difficult, can't remember any. Death Note with their death metal opening I guess, but that is pretty much mainstream music.