Based on the story and such.
People give more importance to the execution in general. What about you guys?
People give more importance to the execution in general. What about you guys?
How do you usually rate anime?
- Thread starter Claraviolet
- Start date
I stopped rating anime.
Why is that?MadaraUchiha said:
Isn't it good to rate anime and help others a little.
Blackangel
Well-known member
i usually rate anime.
but these days i don't bother with it.
but these days i don't bother with it.
But why?If possible you should rate anime when you can.
Like everyone else on the planet I gave 7 to average anime instead of 5 so 8,9 and 10 stopped having any value.Claraviolet said:
You could have given death note a 10.MadaraUchiha said:
I don't see how it could be any better.
I did give it a 10. I can only stop rating something after doing it for a while right... I stopped giving ratings for over 2 years.Claraviolet said:
I see.MadaraUchiha said:
That's ...expected I suppose. I got bored of even adding anime to my list.
Blackangel
Well-known member
bored of even adding anime?
i never thought you would say it that way clarie and it's a very big surprise to me
i never thought you would say it that way clarie and it's a very big surprise to me
Story first that includes the characters on it
HannahCN
Well-known member
I agree you should try to rate anime (and if you can find the energy, anything you watch) whenever you can to help other people. Personally I use IMDb, which has a bit of a harsher rating system than I think most other sites use.
Basically:
5: Not good, but I enjoyed it enough to not fail it.
6: It was okay. Lots of stuff to nitpick, but I enjoyed it.
7: Good. More stuff to like than to dislike, watch when you find the time.
8: Stuff starts to stand out here. Really good. A few things could have been done better, but really, this is starting to boil down more to taste than anything else.
9: Yeah... I *guess* if I want I can find a few things that *maybe* could have been better? I'll recommend you these ones all day long.
10: Perfect. It's basically what a 9 is with a dose of that certain je-ne-sais-quoi that touches the heart, gives you a life lesson to carry with you, or just... Stuff doesn't need to be flawless to be a 10. It needs to make me stop caring that it wasn't. I've only ever rated one anime a 10, and that was A Place Further Than The Universe - and if you've seen it, you know what I'm talking about.
Basically:
5: Not good, but I enjoyed it enough to not fail it.
6: It was okay. Lots of stuff to nitpick, but I enjoyed it.
7: Good. More stuff to like than to dislike, watch when you find the time.
8: Stuff starts to stand out here. Really good. A few things could have been done better, but really, this is starting to boil down more to taste than anything else.
9: Yeah... I *guess* if I want I can find a few things that *maybe* could have been better? I'll recommend you these ones all day long.
10: Perfect. It's basically what a 9 is with a dose of that certain je-ne-sais-quoi that touches the heart, gives you a life lesson to carry with you, or just... Stuff doesn't need to be flawless to be a 10. It needs to make me stop caring that it wasn't. I've only ever rated one anime a 10, and that was A Place Further Than The Universe - and if you've seen it, you know what I'm talking about.
I seeHannahCN said:
Usually people I know give a 10 for Death note. I haven't watched that anime a place further than the universe. I do plan to watch it sometime
Well in the end rating system is just instrument to help people having any idea about how good the series is, but don't forget this system is pretty subjective depend on the taste and preference of the reviewer
HannahCN said:
It's more helpful to use MyAnimeList IMO since it's a lot more comprehensive for anime than IMDB and more people use it. The most number of votes for any anime in IMDB is Spirited Away and it has like 600k votes whereas with MAL there are many with more than a million. And people here use it too.
Blackangel
Well-known member
MadaraUchiha said:
that's really cool to know
and i think many people use imdb because of less ads that can easily be blocked
[quote="grey_fox" pid='188186' dateline='1584847471']
Well in the end rating system is just instrument to help people having any idea about how good the series is, but don't forget this system is pretty subjective depend on the taste and preference of the reviewer
[/quote]
Yeah
No wonder the popularity itself can be biased, based on the region and such
Well in the end rating system is just instrument to help people having any idea about how good the series is, but don't forget this system is pretty subjective depend on the taste and preference of the reviewer
[/quote]
Yeah
No wonder the popularity itself can be biased, based on the region and such
Claraviolet said:
True. That's why popularitas never been the main attraction for me to choose series to enjoy
Grey_Fox said:
There is a reason why a series can be very popular kiddo
Like One piece, Naruto, Bleach, Boku no hero academia etc
Claraviolet said:
It's true but i do have peculiar taste that can't be satisfied by them