Do you think top anime and top manga should be the same?

I've seen some where the changes were better, and some that sucked. So it's not something that someone should be hardlined on one side or the other.

A lot of the comedies are funnier animated. I tried reading some of the manga based on the cute girls doing cute things, and it's nowhere near as entertaining in manga form. It's possible the 4 koma format limited it severely.
 
o.O I am lost.
Do you mean in a list? If so, not all the manga got anime adaptations. So, nope.
 
Like for viewer ratings and such? I think they should be similar as the massive hits of one will also spark a hit on the other side, but it is not perfect. Between the two media types changing content or simply making entirely new stories to the fact that not everything is released together or even at all in some cases, it is too much variation for it to be a 1:1 list. Granted, your top 5 will likely just be the hype anime of the season, but after that things are going to derail rapidly, and as anime ages poorly, the good mangas often stay on top.
 
If you mean should the story be the same then ideally yes. Realistically that will never happen. I have only ever seen 1 movie that was scene for scene verbatim from the book and the books author wrote the screen play, filmed, produced and paid for it all himself. The movie turned out to be a block buster hit too.
 
MoonlightShadow said:
What do you mean by the same?
Click to expand...
take mal list.
should it have the same series name for both anime and manga list?
MadaraUchiha said:
I don't understand the question
Click to expand...
@Claraviolet
the mal list of top anime and manga having the same series name at the top.
kadenmire said:
If you mean should the story be the same then ideally yes. Realistically that will never happen. I have only ever seen 1 movie that was scene for scene verbatim from the book and the books author wrote the screen play, filmed, produced and paid for it all himself. The movie turned out to be a block buster hit too.
Click to expand...
but i mean in a list, kaden
Uncrowned said:
Like for viewer ratings and such? I think they should be similar as the massive hits of one will also spark a hit on the other side, but it is not perfect. Between the two media types changing content or simply making entirely new stories to the fact that not everything is released together or even at all in some cases, it is too much variation for it to be a 1:1 list. Granted, your top 5 will likely just be the hype anime of the season, but after that things are going to derail rapidly, and as anime ages poorly, the good mangas often stay on top.
Click to expand...
that's true lol
for anime the release year matters a lot but for manga the content matters.
 
DarkAngel said:
take mal list.
should it have the same series name for both anime and manga list?

@Claraviolet
the mal list of top anime and manga having the same series name at the top.

but i mean in a list, kaden

that's true lol
for anime the release year matters a lot but for manga the content matters.
Click to expand...

Okay.. that's impossible. Mangas world is bigger than anime, so the list is definitely different
 
No and on what basis do you think they should have the same series?
Do you think all the popular manga will automatically get anime adaptations? That's not true always.
 
MoonlightShadow said:
Okay.. that's impossible. Mangas world is bigger than anime, so the list is definitely different
Click to expand...
i usually think most of the popular manga will usually get anime adaptations.
Rinko said:
No and on what basis do you think they should have the same series?
Do you think all the popular manga will automatically get anime adaptations? That's not true always.
Click to expand...
i thought they would lol
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top