Edward Elric vs. Harry Potter

Elvis

Elvis

V.I.P. Member
Edward Elric from Full Metal Alchemist vs. Harry Potter, the boy wizard who lived from the Harry Potter books and movies.

Who wins?
 
If Harry has the will to kill, he can use the Killing Curse, and if Edward's will isn't strong enough, he can very well use the Imperius curse.....I mean, there are many many spells, etc. which can counter Edward's powers....
 
alakazam said:
Harry can say spells faster than it takes Edward to create alchemy, right?
Click to expand...

Well, I don't think the 'mature' Harry even needs to pronounce all the spells.....I mean, in the sixth book itself, Snape trained all the wizards and witches to cast spells without saying them aloud.....
 
I mean harry could kill practically anyone with his spell's but if it came to physical battle Edward would kick his ass (sorry for language) plus his power of transmutation is amazing UNLESS you are talking about the Edward whom lost his ability to do alchemy i still think Edward's physical ability's would prevail overall
 
Phoenix96ace said:
I mean harry could kill practically anyone with his spell's but if it came to physical battle Edward would kick his ass (sorry for language) plus his power of transmutation is amazing UNLESS you are talking about the Edward whom lost his ability to do alchemy i still think Edward's physical ability's would prevail overall
Click to expand...

Edward is a genius.
He can create alchemy and by the time harry complete his spell, edward can create whatever he wanted out of alchemy.

so, it all depends on the author.
If he wants harry to win, he will or edward will win.
As as anime fan, I want edward to win this battle.
 
Testaccount said:
by the time harry complete his spell, edward can create whatever he wanted out of alchemy.
Click to expand...

Doesn't it usually take Edward a longer time to start up the transmutation process than it takes Harry to say a spell? I mean, saying a word (a spell is usually a word or a couple of words) is faster than creating alchemy.
 
alakazam said:
Doesn't it usually take Edward a longer time to start up the transmutation process than it takes Harry to say a spell? I mean, saying a word (a spell is usually a word or a couple of words) is faster than creating alchemy.
Click to expand...

he can use his hands to create something bro xD
didn't you see fullmetal alchemist until now?
 
Sebastian said:
alakazam said:
Doesn't it usually take Edward a longer time to start up the transmutation process than it takes Harry to say a spell? I mean, saying a word (a spell is usually a word or a couple of words) is faster than creating alchemy.
Click to expand...

he can use his hands to create something bro xD
didn't you see fullmetal alchemist until now?
Click to expand...

i read and watched them both ;)
 
Phoenix96ace said:
i read and watched them both ;)
Click to expand...

i wasn't referring to anything bro xD
but don't you think harry can be easily defeated by edward bro?
 
Sebastian said:
he can use his hands to create something bro xD
didn't you see fullmetal alchemist until now?
Click to expand...
Yes, but what is faster: using your hands to create something (which usually takes a few seconds) or saying two magic words (which takes one second)?
 
alakazam said:
Yes, but what is faster: using your hands to create something (which usually takes a few seconds) or saying two magic words (which takes one second)?
Click to expand...

Using hands. edward is athletic bro and harry is too slow.
edward abilities and attacks are powerful.
Let's ask my bro @Sindar about this XD

Phoenix96ace said:
i read and watched them both ;)
Click to expand...


still you think harry got the advantage here bro?
what is your reason for selecting him?
 
Sebastian said:
Using hands. edward is athletic bro and harry is too slow.
edward abilities and attacks are powerful.
Let's ask my bro @Sindar about this XD
Click to expand...

If you take time thinking about how this fight would go, it is actually pretty interesting. Both HP and FMA stories have this "everything has a catch to it" side, and I can totally see this fight ending in a sad way, where no one would be satisfied with the outcome...

Anyway, I think you can imagine either one winning. Thing is, in FMA Edward is a really strong fighter, and he has deep understanding of how alchemy works. Harry on the other hand is rather a normal guy. He is talented, brave, smart, but he never looked like "top fighter". But that said, if Edward and Harry were to meet, it would likely happen in HP universe (since *Spoilers* Edward was shown to be able to travel through universes, and for Harry Potter it wouldn't make any sense to live in FMA world). And I think it would make sense if Edward was in a disadvantage in that situation, cause he knows nothing of how that world operates. Dunno.
 
Sindar said:
If you take time thinking about how this fight would go, it is actually pretty interesting. Both HP and FMA stories have this "everything has a catch to it" side, and I can totally see this fight ending in a sad way, where no one would be satisfied with the outcome...

Anyway, I think you can imagine either one winning. Thing is, in FMA Edward is a really strong fighter, and he has deep understanding of how alchemy works. Harry on the other hand is rather a normal guy. He is talented, brave, smart, but he never looked like "top fighter". But that said, if Edward and Harry were to meet, it would likely happen in HP universe (since *Spoilers* Edward was shown to be able to travel through universes, and for Harry Potter it wouldn't make any sense to live in FMA world). And I think it would make sense if Edward was in a disadvantage in that situation, cause he knows nothing of how that world operates. Dunno.
Click to expand...

Edward can travel through universes? I totally forgot that.......
 
Saber said:
I don't remember that.
In the last episode?
Click to expand...

How can you forget something like that xD In the end of the series Edward and his father were send to a different version of the world, the version that resembled our world at the end of 19th century. There was this conversation about how the human deaths in this world are the source of power for the alchemy world. At the very end Edward was shown making plans for using technology to get back to his world, in the same dialogue his father even mentioned Einstein.
 
Sindar said:
How can you forget something like that xD In the end of the series Edward and his father were send to a different version of the world, the version that resembled our world at the end of 19th century. There was this conversation about how the human deaths in this world are the source of power for the alchemy world. At the very end Edward was shown making plans for using technology to get back to his world, in the same dialogue his father even mentioned Einstein.
Click to expand...

I do remember that, but he couldn't get back to alfred.
So, he can't exactly switch dimensions at will, sindar.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top