Books/movies vs. manga/anime

MeowsePad

Well-known member
As someone who has watched anime but has not really gotten into manga at any point, I have a question. Would it be fair to say that watching an anime without reading the manga is like watching a movie without reading the book? Do most anime leave out things or rush through things that were developed much more carefully in manga? Are all anime based on manga?
 
I would go for anime/manga anytime.
They are good and not boring like movies and books.

That's a typical anime fan for you
 
Most anime I've watched are pretty close to the manga version(say 85-90%), but, that may not be the case with movies/novels, and you know the reason: time......
 
MadaraUchiha said:
Most anime I've watched are pretty close to the manga version(say 85-90%), but, that may not be the case with movies/novels, and you know the reason: time......

I do agree with this. In my opinion, the producers want to have at least the distinguishable difference between the manga and the anime (and sometimes, the anime does the difference good) so to attract viewers to patronize the latter more. But as what others say, either of the two is fun to read.
 
I think a fairer comparison is series/books vs anime/manga (or perhaps movies/comics), of which admittedly there are far fewer examples. You have to take into account that a movie has to tell the story of an entire book in ~2 hours, whereas an anime has at least, let's say, 5-6 hours (12 episodes times ~25 minutes). As such, a movie based on a book is almost assuredly going to leave things out. In the end though, if it can still grab your attention and hold it for all of those 2 hours, it might even be better value for your time than an anime which might sometimes be forced to add filler episodes because they've used up all of the currently available source material (another issue movies based on books don't have, since a book, even if it's a book in a series, is almost always going to be, a finished story, whereas manga-based anime are often still ongoing). In the end, I think it's hard to compare most of the time. They're different media, and as such, different rules apply.
 
HannahCN said:
I think a fairer comparison is series/books vs anime/manga (or perhaps movies/comics), of which admittedly there are far fewer examples. You have to take into account that a movie has to tell the story of an entire book in ~2 hours, whereas an anime has at least, let's say, 5-6 hours (12 episodes times ~25 minutes). As such, a movie based on a book is almost assuredly going to leave things out. In the end though, if it can still grab your attention and hold it for all of those 2 hours, it might even be better value for your time than an anime which might sometimes be forced to add filler episodes because they've used up all of the currently available source material (another issue movies based on books don't have, since a book, even if it's a book in a series, is almost always going to be, a finished story, whereas manga-based anime are often still ongoing). In the end, I think it's hard to compare most of the time. They're different media, and as such, different rules apply.

this is true
but what do you enjoy the most is important
 
HannahCN said:
Absolutely - no one lives forever, so just spend your time on the stuff you like. =)

right hannah
and thank you for that. i should get a life too and not worry about others all the time
 
Back
Top